Delta council denied a proposed townhouse development in Ladner this week after a number of residents came forward with concerns about the design.
The three-unit project was slated for the lot behind the former Ladner Baptist Church building on 47A Avenue and Delta Street.
Earlier this year, restoration work began on the former church. The small house beside the church, which was used as a parsonage, was demolished last summer and the church building was moved six feet closer to 47A Avenue.
Several residents voiced concerns about the form, character and height of the proposed development.
Local architect and planner Brian Hart told council members at a public hearing Monday night the simple, modern design was chosen to ensure the new development would not detract from the restored church building.
Many of the residents that spoke in opposition to the look of the proposal stressed they were not opposed to the development but had concerns the modern look was not in keeping with the rest of the neighbourhood.
"The development of the church has been incredible and I commend the developer," said resident David Roberts, adding the townhouses "would stick out like a sore thumb."
"I don't find it complementary in its form or character," said resident John Dean, who owns two nearby properties. "I think what the people in the area want is something that fits into the area."
Many of the residents that spoke at the public hearing asked council to refer the proposal back to staff to work with the proponent on redesigning it with a more heritage style.
At the regular council meeting later on Monday night, Coun. Robert Campbell agreed and moved to deny the application, saying that development at the site wasn't the issue but the form and character of the design were problems.
Coun. Scott Hamilton agreed with Campbell's motion to reject the application.
He said that if council sent the proposal back to staff for revision there would have to be so many changes it would necessitate another public hearing.
"We all want to move forward in the next 20 or 25 years to have Ladner Village have a theme that fits in with the heritage look of Ladner," said Coun. Ian Paton.
Delta chief administrative officer George Harvie said a temporary occupancy permit can be issued for the church in order for that building to be available for use.
